Thriftier Thrift Store Shopping in Today’s Economy: 10 Tips

In this article: Tips to help you save money at thrift stores during inflationary times without sacrificing the joy of discovering amazing bargains on unique finds.

by Andrea Norris-McKnight

Do you love the search for elusive bargains and sensational steals? Then you probably love thrift stores. Thrift stores are a haven for bargain hunters and sustainable shoppers, offering a unique blend of eclectic finds and budget-friendly prices.

However, the landscape of thrift shopping is changing. With inflation impacting nearly every facet of the economy, even the once reliably affordable thrift store prices have seen a noticeable uptick. This shift has left many wondering how to continue finding great deals amidst rising costs.

Even though thrift stores aren’t as thrifty as they once were, you can still save considerably over buying new. And the following tips can help you in your quest for thriftier thrift store shopping finds.

10 Tips for Thriftier Thrift Store Shopping

It’s essential to shop smart, even at thrift stores. Here are ten savvy tips to help you save money without sacrificing the joy of discovering amazing bargains and unique finds.

1. Shop with a list or a dollar limit.

Approaching thrift shopping with a strategy can significantly enhance your savings. Before stepping into a store, make a list of items you truly need or set a strict budget for your visit.

This focused approach prevents impulse buys and ensures you only spend on items that add value to your life or wardrobe.

2. Allow plenty of time to shop.

For many of us, the thrill of thrift store shopping lies in the hunt. Allowing ample time to sift through racks and shelves can help you uncover the best deals. Rushed shopping might result in overlooked gems or unnecessary purchases.

Dedicate a few hours to the thrifting experience and enjoy the leisurely pursuit of bargains.

Sign Up for Savings

Subscribe to get money-saving content by email that can help you stretch your dollars further.

Twice each week, you'll receive articles and tips that can help you free up and keep more of your hard-earned money, even on the tightest of budgets.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

3. Shop in and out-of-season items.

Like retail stores, thrift stores often have items that are out of season, such as winter coats in the summer or swimsuits in the winter. Thrift stores may discount out-of-season items heavily to remove them from inventory.

Likewise, thrift stores often run sales on in-season items that have been in the store too long to make room for new merchandise.

4. Stick to quality items.

Quality over quantity is a mantra worth adopting in thrift stores. Inspect items for durability, brand reputation and overall condition. Investing in higher-quality, gently used items ensures longevity and saves money in the long run, as you’ll avoid the need for frequent replacements.

5. Look for unique finds.

One of the joys of thrift shopping is stumbling upon unique or vintage pieces that stand out. These items can add character and style to your collection or home and may hold or increase their value over time. Keep an eye out for distinctive pieces that resonate with your style or that of someone you can gift the item to.

Also, try to avoid purchasing items similar to things you already own. Buying another black dress when you already have two in your closet is not saving money, no matter how good the bargain.

6. Shop on discount days and during sales.

Many thrift stores offer special discount days, seasonal sales, or loyalty programs that can lead to significant savings. Familiarize yourself with the sales calendar of your favorite stores and plan your shopping trips accordingly. Student, military or senior discounts can also apply, so don’t hesitate to ask.

Additionally, some thrift stores may have year-round clearance sections where you can find items at deeply discounted prices.

7. Subscribe or follow your favorite thrift stores on social media.

You might think your inbox is already full enough these days, or you’re following more people online than you can keep up with. But staying in touch with your favorite thrift stores via social media or email subscriptions can help you save.

Stores often announce exclusive deals, special event sales, or new stock arrivals online, giving you the inside scoop on the best times to shop via email and social media. And some stores give a discount on every purchase to email subscribers.

8. Pay with cash or debit.

Retailers must pay a fee for each credit card purchase they process. Some thrift stores may pass that fee on to the consumer. You can often save a small percentage on your purchases by paying with cash or a debit card since the store does not incur a fee for processing these forms of payment.

Using cash or a debit card also helps maintain a tangible sense of your spending and can curb the temptation to go over budget. This practice encourages mindful purchasing and keeps your thrift shopping adventures financially responsible.

9. Donate items.

Before heading out to the thrift store, consider decluttering your space and donating items you no longer need. Some stores offer discount coupons or vouchers in exchange for donations, providing a dual benefit of clearing out space at home for new finds and saving money on future purchases.

10. Watch for items you can flip for a profit.

For those with an entrepreneurial spirit, thrift shopping can also serve as a source of income. Keep an eye out for underpriced items with potential resale value. You may be able to flip vintage clothing, collectibles, or unique home decor pieces online for a profit.

Thriftier Thrift Store Shopping Is Possible Despite the Economy

In an era where the charm of thrift shopping meets the challenge of inflation, finding ways to save money while indulging in this eco-friendly and rewarding hobby has become more crucial than ever. By adopting these 10 tips, you can enhance your thrift shopping experience, ensuring it remains a fruitful and enjoyable pursuit.

Reviewed March 2024

About the Author

Andrea Norris-McKnight took over as the editor of The Dollar Stretcher and After 50 Finances after working under the site founder and previous editor for almost 15 years. She has also written for Money.com, GOBankingRates.com, HavenLife.com and The Sacramento Bee.